Best pizza restaurant in Cicero, IN

J.R. White

What a nice little hidden gem. Great food! Comes out fast and HOT! Gotta let it cool a bit before taking your first bite, but I don't mind that in the least. The people are friendly. It's a pretty small space, and tight in there, but that doesn't bother me. Definitely recommend.

Speakeasy Ranch

best pizza ever!!! They only use fresh ingredients and load up toppings! The owner is so sweet and cares about her customers.

Cedric Wilson

+ five more stars. great pizza, excellent customer service. had a pick-up order for a gathering of 15-20 people (3 large pizzas and a tray of 24pc chicken); it was hot and ready to go at the specified time, pick-up was easy (even for a busy saturday night). the chicken was a hit, folks were asking over and over ... about the pizza, seriously Bronko's is a treasure trove if you like good food. we visited a few other times to dine-in, i'm always greeted always and have a friendly face serving me. will definitely return regularly! Read More

Alicia

Bread sticks and cheese pizza with original crust were good! My husband liked his thin crust pepperoni and banana peppers pizza. Service was friendly and the dining area was nice and clean!

Amanda S

First time experience. Pizza was delicious, bottom of crust was a little too hard for me but it still tasted amazing. Would have liked to try their fried chicken, but they weren’t selling individual pieces the evening that we were there. Service was excellent and we will be back.

Beth Beck

First time eating at Bronko’s. The dining room is narrow with cozy booths along the wall opposite the kitchen. We ordered the breadsticks along with a couple of pizzas. The breadsticks were fantastic! We really loved the garlic dipping sauce with them. The pizzas were both good, a cheese and a combination one. The ... pizza crust was a little thin for our taste. I wish the crust was the same as the breadsticks. Still, they were both good. Service was fast and friendly. I can’t wait to go back for more breadsticks the next time we are in Cicero. Read More

Dodd Berry

Wonderful little restaurant. Service was quite friendly. Seems a lot of customers were carryout but we sat and ate in and it was very enjoyable. We each had a personal pizza and it was wonderful. The whole menu had a Chicago flair to it. Next trip I'll try one of their sandwiches.

Madison Adams

We had a great meal! The bread sticks and cheese pizza with original crust were good, and my husband really liked his thin crust with pepperoni and banana peppers. The service was friendly, and we especially appreciated that the dining area was nice and clean! A great spot for a reliable pizza dinner.

Alyssa Barnes

We received great service. The breadsticks were made great they were nice and crunchy on the outside and soft and delicious on the inside. The wings were good. Half of our group really loved the pizza. I wasn’t a huge fan but it wasn’t a bad pizza. I felt it left something to be desired. Everything comes right out to ... you hot and fresh. The staff is wonderful. Read More